The piece argues that mobile users need a credible third option beyond Android and iOS because both ecosystems increasingly limit people’s control over their devices and software. iOS has always been tightly controlled, while Android’s openness is narrowing as Google introduces requirements that could make installing apps outside approved channels costly, slow, and difficult. Alternative Android ROMs such as LineageOS or GrapheneOS may not solve the problem if apps and services begin blocking them. This contrasts with personal computers, where owners can readily replace an operating system and run software of their choice. As essential services increasingly depend on smartphone apps, reliance on two foreign technology companies also raises concerns about access, civic participation, and digital sovereignty.
A viable alternative should have an open-source core, support multiple ways to distribute software, and prioritize interoperability. It should not simply reproduce a closed corporate ecosystem, nor fragment into small projects too obscure to attract users and developers. The author argues that building a new system from scratch is difficult, so people seeking change should support an existing project with a community and independent development. The candidates named are SailfishOS, Nura, formerly known as postmarketOS, and Ubuntu Touch. After recently moving a device from Android to Ubuntu Touch, the author plans to test these systems and perhaps contribute, while stressing that the important outcome is for at least one of them to gain meaningful adoption.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.