Mark Zlochin argues that Wikipedia’s English-language entry on Zionism has shifted from a broadly sourced account toward a partisan framing since October 2023. His analysis of its revision history finds that roughly 80 percent of the text was replaced by mid-2026, despite the page’s two decades of development and more than 9,000 edits. The rewrite, he says, expanded discussion of colonialism by about two and a half times and ethnic cleansing by about twice, while cutting material on antisemitism and persecution by half and making Jewish return to the historic homeland the least prominent of four themes.
Zlochin highlights a new opening claim that Zionists sought a Jewish state with as much land and as many Jews, and as few Palestinian Arabs, as possible. It is supported by 17 citations, but the editor who added it was later banned from editing in the Israel-Palestine topic area; Wikipedia also barred debate over removing the sentence for a year. Zlochin says no new evidence or major scholarly shift accounts for the rewrite, which instead reflects editorial choices that foreground critical interpretations and misrepresent scholarship. He focuses on historian Benny Morris, whose archival research documented expulsions and other Israeli actions in 1948 while rejecting both claims of voluntary Palestinian flight and a preplanned Zionist expulsion. Zlochin contends the revised entry erases that complexity.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.