hn.today

Port Scanning for Mojang

sipacid.com9 points0 comments
Screenshot of Port Scanning for Mojang

A hobbyist revived Slowstack, a tool that scans the internet for Minecraft servers and displays their details, then discovered Mojang was using its API. Mojang initially contacted him to troubleshoot the service; later, he found logs showing searches for servers with offensive descriptions. By matching Slowstack’s records against Mojang’s published list of banned IP addresses and domains, he identified servers that appeared to have been banned for their descriptions, including private servers. Although Mojang’s rules prohibit abusive or obscene content, they do not specifically mention server descriptions. To test whether descriptions were the reason, the author had friends create private, whitelist-only servers with mildly inappropriate text; those servers were banned within a week.

The author argues that Mojang was relying on third-party hobbyist scanners to identify and ban servers, rather than collecting the information itself, leaving operators with little explanation beyond intimidating notices forwarded by internet providers. He acknowledges that some banned servers may have violated rules in other ways, but presents the controlled tests as evidence that server descriptions alone could trigger enforcement. Mojang later asked him to add scanning for Bedrock Edition and, after he shut the project down, requested data exports and indirectly its source code. He refused, criticizing the company for obtaining potentially consequential data from unpaid volunteers while leaving server owners to handle complaints and bans.

Read on sipacid.com0 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Web

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.