Meta says it may consider withdrawing encrypted services from Canada if Bill C-22 passes without further changes. The proposed lawful-access legislation would require technology companies to make information available to investigators with a warrant and allow the public safety minister to order electronic service providers to build surveillance and monitoring capabilities into their systems. Meta argues that complying with the bill while maintaining secure, end-to-end encryption is technically impossible: government amendments limit when companies must decrypt information, but, Meta says, do not protect the surrounding components needed for encryption. The amendments also cut the maximum metadata-retention period from a year to six months.
Meta’s warning echoes Signal’s statement that it would leave Canada rather than weaken users’ security, and Apple’s concern that the bill could compromise its privacy protections. The government says the powers are needed to help law enforcement prevent and investigate modern crime. Critics, including Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne, say further changes are required. He objects that the bill would lower the threshold for obtaining basic subscriber details - such as names, addresses and account numbers - from reasonable grounds to believe an offence has occurred or is planned to reasonable grounds to suspect one, while leaving the information’s definition and the range of authorities able to request it too broad. The bill is under Senate review.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.