The Apollo “grenade launcher” was described as part of an active seismic experiment, not a weapon: its mortar package fired four explosive charges to send vibrations through the lunar surface for scientific study. One commenter cited a NASA manual describing Earth commands that armed and fired the charges. Others joked about aliens or a haunted Moon, while one wondered how far a conventional grenade launcher could shoot in lunar gravity.
The Soviet space gun prompted a separate debate about survival after off-target landings in remote Siberia. Some commenters argued that a firearm was sensible protection against bears or wolves while waiting days for rescue; others said attacks were uncommon or that a pistol should have sufficed. Supporters pointed to the remoteness of landing sites and the custom TP-82, a shotgun-and-rifle combination, while one commenter offered the more speculative claim that a gun might serve as a means of suicide if a crew were stranded. A discussion of a gun mounted on the Salyut 3 station raised questions about aiming and maneuvering in orbit. Opinion also divided over moderation: some valued discouraging joke-only posts to preserve useful discussion, while others saw strictness about humor as needlessly joyless.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.