Commenters described the speaker as practical feedback during dialing and connection, not merely a way to hear the modem’s characteristic noises. It let users catch a wrong number when a person answered, hear busy or dial tones, and monitor whether dialing and connection were progressing. Several said they could recognize the handshake and judge whether a connection was likely to reach a good speed, then hang up and retry. One commenter argued that users had to listen because they could not always trust the modem to establish a good connection on its own; another noted that audible dialing could help reveal a program calling out without the user’s knowledge.
Other commenters emphasized hands-on control and the speaker’s low cost. One used its sound to tune modem timing for faster redialing, identify callers, and play pranks on other BBS operators. Their wardialing story also illustrated the hazards of automated dialing: a call to emergency services did not disconnect as expected. Others recalled the speaker as a simple, inexpensive hardware feature, and one expressed nostalgia for an era when manufacturers would include such parts rather than cut costs. The emphasis varied - from troubleshooting and security to experimentation and economy - but commenters generally treated the sound as useful information for users, not an unnecessary extra.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.