The washed-out appearance of early 3dfx graphics came largely from a mismatch in gamma handling, rather than simply from 16-bit color. 3dfx used a relatively linear color response: pixel values corresponded more directly to emitted light, making operations such as blending and texture filtering physically sensible. But the textures artists supplied were typically painted for conventional, nonlinear displays. Shown through 3dfx’s more linear pipeline without correction, those images looked pale and lacked the intended contrast and color.
Linear color is well suited to professional systems with at least 10 bits per channel, which can represent brightness finely enough. Early 3dfx hardware had only 5 or 6 bits per channel, so dividing values evenly across light intensity wasted levels in bright regions and left too few for dark tones. Human vision is more sensitive to relative changes in dim areas, making those gaps conspicuous as bands. Textures made specifically for 3dfx could have improved the mismatch in appearance, but limited precision would still have caused dark banding. Carmack recalls that developers focused on 3dfx’s performance and did not adequately correct texture gamma in the glQuake era. Gamma mistakes also persist in modern games, sometimes visible as subtle shimmer in high-contrast textures and edges.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.