The Electronic Frontier Foundation and the ACLU have asked the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals to require police to obtain a warrant before searching automated license plate reader (ALPR) records. Their request comes in United States v. Sturdivant, which concerns robberies near Cleveland. Police used camera footage to identify the suspected getaway car’s make, model, and color, then searched Flock and ELSAG databases without a warrant. Those searches showed that a car owned by the defendant had been recorded near robbery locations, helping police identify and arrest him.
The district court rejected the defendant’s challenge, reasoning that license plates are visible in public and therefore their owners have no reasonable expectation of privacy in them. The groups argue that this treats isolated observation as equivalent to searchable, long-term tracking. ALPR cameras record passing vehicles along with the time and location, creating interconnected records that let police reconstruct past movements with a database search. They contend that this capability amounts to a Fourth Amendment search, rather than ordinary observation of a car on a public road. The brief draws on their prior legal challenges to ALPR systems and a recent federal ruling describing the technology as indiscriminate mass surveillance that can violate constitutional protections. They want the appeals court to reverse the district court and establish that retrospective searches of ALPR data require a warrant.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.