Vibecoding’s ability to reproduce complex, industry-standard software is presented as resolved: the delay in seeing Photoshop replacements reflected time and development pressure, not impossibility. Photoshop is singled out as an ideal proving ground because its behavior can be verified against the PSD/PSB standard - layers, blend modes, smart objects, adjustment layers, effects and font rendering expose implementation fidelity. Multiple recent projects now demonstrate that agentic coding can produce workable clones; their very existence falsifies the argument that such software cannot be built, and remaining bugs are framed as fixable iteration rather than disqualifying flaws.
Four concrete candidates are evaluated. Photon Studio is the most polished: cross-platform binaries, reliable PSD load/save (including smart objects, blend modes and effects), and integrations for local AI models and agent harnesses. OmaPhoto (a Linux port of Compositor) imports PSDs but currently flattens smart objects and leans on a .comp format that complicates round-trip PSD interop. PhotoCraft, a clean-room Rust reimplementation, exports PSDs but misinterprets some color adjustments and has limited smart-object editing. PhotoSuite offers the closest UI parity and mostly correct colors but also can’t fully edit smart objects yet. Several other OSS projects (Patchy, Xuan) are mentioned, underscoring that multiple viable, rapidly improving Photoshop alternatives already exist.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.