hn.today

Vacate a Drone Restriction That Criminalized Recording Immigration Agents

eff.org87 points18 comments
Screenshot of Vacate a Drone Restriction That Criminalized Recording Immigration Agents

Commenters debated a contested FAA drone restriction that had criminalized flights near certain federal mobile assets and the Electronic Frontier Foundation's push to have it vacated. dji4321234 said the rule was already rescinded and replaced by an advisory/NOTAM, and characterized the EFF effort as seeking a retroactive legal finding of illegality. rahimnathwani and nkrisc argued the 3,000 ft/1,000 ft standoff was effectively impossible to comply with - raising practical enforcement and notice problems - while TGower criticized the original piece for ignoring safety concerns and praised the NOTAM as a better, more targeted solution. petcat noted that petitioners need not present the FAA’s safety case in their filing, and others offered analogies and cynicism about enforcement.

The thread split along civil‑liberties and safety lines. Users like ck2 emphasized the value of drone recording to expose alleged ICE abuses and detention conditions, arguing surveillance bans silence accountability; ourmandave cataloged common public rationalizations that diminish migrant suffering. Nemomarx acknowledged a safety angle (recorders could conceal threats) but said that does not justify a blanket ban. Overall, commenters divided between those prioritizing transparency and protection of recording rights and those more willing to accept FAA safety/security rationales or pragmatic regulatory fixes.

Read on eff.org18 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Security

AI Exec: We May Have Pulled Off "The Largest Theft of Labor in Human History"

AI Exec: We May Have Pulled Off "The Largest Theft of Labor in Human History"

Documents from a lawsuit reveal that AI companies like OpenAI and Microsoft may have committed the largest theft of labor in history by training their models on copyrighted content without permission. Executives discussed concerns about AI's potential to destabilize the economy and the internet, highlighting unfiltered views on legal and ethical issues. (motherjones.com)

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.