hn.today

Update on Code of Conduct Actions

discourse.gnome.org4 points0 comments
Screenshot of Update on Code of Conduct Actions

GNOME Foundation Interim Executive Director Allan Day reports that the Code of Conduct Committee reviewed complaints about a controversial September Mastodon exchange involving GNOME project members. Applying its process for assessing harm and the likelihood of repeated behavior, the committee found multiple Code of Conduct violations and recommended temporary suspensions of different lengths, due to begin November 10. The Foundation says the sanctions are intended to uphold a safe, welcoming community, and asks members to respect those affected. Day also acknowledges a delay in responding, apologizes, and says the Foundation will act faster in future. He notes that some reports went missing because of a technical problem, now fixed, and urges people to report misconduct.

The announcement’s lack of names, reasons, and suspension lengths prompts criticism that GNOME’s governance and Code of Conduct process are opaque. Two suspended contributors disclose receiving 10-day bans; one shares a decision letter citing harassment, personal attacks after another member had blocked him, and language that intensified conflict. Critics argue that penalizing people who spoke up against harmful behavior amounts to tone policing and may undermine protections for marginalized members. Another commenter says they are still awaiting decisions on reports alleging ageist and transphobic remarks in the same exchange, raising doubts about whether complaints were addressed consistently. The discussion centers on whether the committee’s actions were fair and protective, and whether secrecy and delayed communication have further damaged trust.

Read on discourse.gnome.org0 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.