hn.today

Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances

science.org180 points66 comments
Screenshot of Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances

The proposed communication method uses changes in nearby mass and their gravitational effects, measured with a gravimeter, rather than electromagnetic signals. Some commenters saw broader uses, such as tracking a position with an array of gravimeters, and one welcomed the idea as an interesting engineering project: taking a principle that works in theory and trying to improve its range and bandwidth. Another joked that the technology might be useful before the Trisolarans arrive. The very low reported rate - about one bit per minute - prompted mockery and doubts about practical value.

Commenters disagreed over whether the signal is genuinely hard to block. One argued that a large, unpredictably moving mass, such as a double pendulum, could disrupt transmission; another cited the claim that active interference could degrade the signal by moving masses or causing vibrations. Skeptics said that flooding the environment with noise would be analogous to jamming radio, and questioned whether a communication system with such a narrow use case solves a real problem. Others distinguished active jamming from passive shielding: gravity cannot be screened in the same way as electromagnetic signals, they noted, while another commenter pointed out that Faraday cages do block some EM communications. Overall, commenters treated “unblockable” as a distinction from passive shielding, not immunity to interference, and differed on whether that distinction makes the method useful.

Read on science.org66 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Science

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.