The UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal has rejected the government’s attempt to keep secret whether it issued Apple a Technical Capability Notice under the Investigatory Powers Act. The government must now acknowledge that it gave Apple such an order, after arguing that disclosure could harm national security by revealing which companies receive notices. The tribunal found that the government had not shown that confirming this particular notice would create that risk. The ruling does not establish whether the order was lawful, reveal what Apple was required to do, or decide whether the government can compel changes to encryption.
The dispute began with reports in 2025 that the UK had ordered Apple to enable access to encrypted iCloud data, potentially affecting users worldwide. Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection feature for new UK users rather than weaken its protections, while existing users who had enabled it retained the feature. This created different levels of protection among UK customers. After the original notice was withdrawn amid diplomatic pressure, the government reportedly issued a replacement limited to UK users, and Apple brought a fresh legal challenge. Civil liberties groups Liberty and Privacy International are also challenging the secrecy and safeguards of the notice regime. The decision makes those proceedings easier to scrutinize, but broader questions about government powers, privacy, and the future of encryption remain unresolved, with a substantive hearing expected in 2027.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.