K-12 classrooms have shifted from reusable textbooks and paper tests to Chromebooks, subscription platforms, and gamified apps that reward students with tokens and cartoon characters. Children may experience these systems as play rather than learning, while teachers and families have little clear evidence that the games improve understanding. The essay links this change to private investment: New York City schools paid millions of dollars to companies such as Amplify, Curriculum Associates, and HMH, several backed by venture capital or private equity. It also details legal challenges to i-Ready, including allegations that its assessments do not deliver the personalized instruction they advertise; Curriculum Associates denies wrongdoing.
The central argument is that digital education has made public schools dependent on companies that can profit from student data, ongoing subscriptions, and software upgrades - a relationship likened to “technofeudalism.” Unlike textbooks, platforms can collect children’s work and personal information, and access can vanish when contracts end. Google’s decision to let schools disable its new AI tools only if they also give up Google Search illustrates how companies can use their control over essential services to pressure schools. Meanwhile, proposed AI pilots face opposition from educators and families who question their educational value and warn of risks to students’ development and privacy. The essay argues that public schools, especially those serving many children in poverty, should not become markets for private capital’s technology experiments.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.