hn.today

The Legend of von Neumann [pdf]

gwern.net220 points125 comments
Screenshot of The Legend of von Neumann [pdf]

Commenters celebrated von Neumann’s prodigious mind with anecdotes and book recommendations: Edward Teller’s quip about him conversing on equal footing with a three‑year‑old, tales of blasting German marching bands while working, an ability to memorize and calculate instantly, and eccentric personal habits (staring, loving money). Several recommended biographies and literary takes - The Man from the Future, The MANIAC, Turing’s Cathedral - and praised Paul Halmos’s clear writing. Others noted his membership in the Hungarian “Martians” circle and pointed to Halmos’s essay as a readable snapshot of a figure many called their favorite mathematician or a uniquely multidisciplinary genius.

Opinion split over how to interpret that genius. Some claimed von Neumann was more influential in 20th‑century science than Einstein or Planck (srejk), while others questioned which of his contributions were truly original versus opportunistic problem‑solving (gradus_ad). A few argued his rapid intellect won’t shape future mathematics the way athletic prowess doesn’t transform sport (tbagman) and tied the discussion to AI’s role in math. Debates touched on attribution (who deserves credit for “von Neumann architecture”), accounts of his decline and possible whitewashing (inasio citing Dyson), and whether modern institutions already house comparable intellects (brcmthrowaway).

Read on gwern.net125 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Science

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.