hn.today

The Bitter Lesson is Coming for Software Engineering

twitter.com10 points3 comments
Screenshot of The Bitter Lesson is Coming for Software Engineering

Coding agents are currently given freedom to implement solutions within structures humans prescribe: codebase organization, services, interfaces, abstractions, and coding standards. This arrangement resembles early machine learning, when people engineered features to guide models before larger datasets and more computing let general learning systems discover effective representations for themselves. The argument is that architecture is also a form of feature engineering, and human design judgment may eventually limit rather than improve results. Engineers now correct agents’ mistakes, supply missing context such as product plans and operational constraints, and anticipate the long-term effects of design choices. As models improve and gain access to more of that context and evidence, these contributions may become less necessary.

The proposed shift is from designing systems directly to designing the feedback and incentives that let agents discover good systems. That means defining what successful software should achieve, then giving agents ways to test and learn from outcomes. Unlike image recognition, software quality has no simple universal score: it involves trade-offs among speed of delivery, correctness, security, reliability, scalability, and ease of future change, with priorities varying across teams and companies. The measure of success should be how well a system serves those goals, not whether its architecture matches what a senior engineer would have chosen. This change could make accumulated human expertise less central, and turn engineers’ work toward building guardrails and feedback loops that help agents learn what good software is.

Read on twitter.com3 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in AI

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.