hn.today

Stop Filming in Log

digitalfilms.wordpress.com59 points63 comments
Screenshot of Stop Filming in Log

A veteran colorist argues that log recording is often adopted as a supposed route to a film look, or as a way to postpone exposure decisions, but can instead make footage harder to manage. Log and raw formats were developed to preserve broad dynamic range for later adjustment; they are not inherently more film-like, and underexposed log footage may not grade well. Film negative itself is exposed properly and corrected during printing, so it is not a direct equivalent to digital log. Camera makers’ log profiles also vary, often requiring different lookup tables, with uneven results. The writer prefers ARRI and Panasonic log implementations, and favors Sony’s S-Cinetone over its numerous alternatives.

Raw can offer useful post-production control, but the writer says it is not essential when footage is exposed with a Rec. 709 image in mind. HDR video is also treated skeptically: unlike how human vision adapts between bright and dark areas, HDR displays can show both at once, producing harsh images, especially in dim viewing environments. Although some cameras, streaming platforms, and theatrical systems support HDR, it remains limited in practice. The recommendation is to avoid HDR recording unless the delivery specifically requires it, and for many projects choose a correctly exposed, low-contrast Rec. 709 profile. That approach, the writer contends, often yields better-looking footage and a simpler grading workflow than relying on log, raw, or HDR.

Read on digitalfilms.wordpress.com63 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.