Safari, Chrome, and Firefox can save a dragged URL as a .webloc file that opens the link in a browser. The files are property lists: Chrome and Firefox still create XML versions, while Safari switched from XML to binary sometime around early 2023. In macOS 27.2, Safari-created files began triggering a warning that they had been downloaded from the internet and would open Safari. The warning appeared inconsistently: some people saw it immediately after upgrading, while the writer first encountered it more than a week later, despite having opened a saved link without trouble the previous day.
The likely trigger is the com.apple.quarantine attribute, which Safari has attached to binary .webloc files since at least 2023, though it previously caused no warning. Converting a file to XML with plutil removes that attribute and avoids the alert; files made by Chrome or Firefox also lack it and open normally. The writer questions why a URL saved locally by dragging it from Safari is treated as an internet download, and whether the change reflects a real security risk in binary .webloc files. The timing and rollout mechanism remain unexplained, as does why Safari’s files are treated differently from equivalent links created by other browsers.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.