hn.today

Llms.txt and MCP didn't move the needle

backpackforlaravel.com31 points21 comments
Screenshot of Llms.txt and MCP didn't move the needle

Backpack for Laravel’s maintainer says AI coding agents have cut admin-panel work from days to hours, but the biggest gains did not come from adding an llms.txt file or a documentation-only MCP server. Agents seldom choose to fetch those resources, and poorly framed searches can return useless results. The package’s stronger advantages grew out of decisions made for human developers: a stable API that models have encountered in years of examples, an extensive open-source footprint, readable source code - including paid add-ons installed in vendor - and simple extension points that let agents make changes in few files. Stability matters because models may keep reproducing old patterns after an API rename; deprecating or aliasing is preferable to breaking familiar signatures.

Purpose-built improvements help when they put guidance directly in the agent’s context. A Laravel Boost plugin supplies version-matched instructions and topic-specific skills without requiring the agent to request them. CLI generators reliably create CRUD scaffolding and tests, avoiding repetitive hand-written boilerplate. Consistent names and argument patterns make related features easier for agents to infer, while serving documentation as Markdown offers a smaller convenience. The practical priority is therefore to provide in-project instructions, preserve APIs, keep code readable, automate repeated scaffolding, reduce customization ceremony, and make conventions predictable. The broader argument is that ordinary software qualities - clarity, stability, and useful tools - also make packages easier for AI agents to use; llms.txt and static-docs MCP are low priorities without a specific use case.

Read on backpackforlaravel.com21 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in AI

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.