hn.today

Lady Gaga, Lena Dunham and surrogacy: Why isn't it causing a scandal in the US?

english.elpais.com17 points23 comments
Screenshot of Lady Gaga, Lena Dunham and surrogacy: Why isn't it causing a scandal in the US?

Several high-profile women - Lady Gaga and Lena Dunham via surrogacy, and Millie Bobby Brown via adoption - became mothers within days, provoking warm public reaction in the United States and little ethical uproar. The contrast with Europe is stark: many European countries ban commercial surrogacy or restrict it to altruistic arrangements (Spain criminalized it as a form of violence in 2022), while in the U.S. surrogacy is legal in most states, expensive (often exceeding $100,000), and growing rapidly. Embryo transfers for surrogacy tripled between 2010 and 2019, the industry generated about $176 million in 2022 and is projected to exceed $303 million by 2031. Only Louisiana outlaws surrogacy outright; several states restrict contracts but the practice persists. Bioethicist Arthur Caplan attributes American acceptance to a stronger market mindset and genetic determinism, and calls for regulation rather than prohibition.

Public debate is muted in part because media coverage of celebrity births emphasizes emotional narratives of parenthood, obscuring systemic issues: surrogate compensation, economic pressures on carriers, agency practices, and legal protections. Feminist voices split - Gloria Steinem condemned commercial surrogacy as exploitative while Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie defended ethical arrangements - prompting scholars to urge discussion focused on rights, oversight and equitable safeguards instead of personal choices. Concluding view: widespread bans are unlikely in the U.S.; pragmatic regulation and scrutiny of the industry’s practices are the pressing policy priorities.

Read on english.elpais.com23 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.