The fine centers on Meta’s request for access to Android users’ photo galleries. Commenters clarified that the issue was not alleged covert, random uploading: the permission covered multiple app features, while a generic warning did not clearly explain that photos and videos could be used for suggestions. Some argued users had granted access and the penalty was excessive; others said a broad permission prompt does not amount to informed consent. Several questioned whether fines change Meta’s behavior, calling them a cost of doing business, while another commenter said court orders can force concrete changes and limit future abuses.
Commenters also divided over the purpose and scale of the penalties. Some viewed them as necessary enforcement against a powerful company they consider harmful, and said Meta should comply or leave the European market. Others portrayed billion-dollar fines as a stealth tax or revenue source for governments, and questioned whether the amounts are proportionate. More broadly, some said persistent criticism of Meta reflects its conduct and a tech industry turned toward lock-in and profit; others saw HN’s negativity as part of a wider preference for outrage, arguing that it obscures technology’s positive contributions.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.