Shane Melaugh argues that Claude Opus 5.5’s reasoning behavior changed abruptly on November 3, even though its model name remained the same. He says he had Gemini 4 Argon examine 1,400 Claude Code sessions and found a sharp shift in how the model reasoned. In a follow-up, he adds that Opus 5.5 in “high” mode began using substantially less reasoning. The claim is that this change could explain why some users feel the model has become less capable, rather than their experience being imagined.
Melaugh also describes a test on a real software bug: Opus 5.5 in high mode reportedly started acting too quickly, became confused, and failed to find a fix after three hours. In contrast, the “xhigh” setting paused to think and solved the bug within minutes. He concludes that the advice to use high mode for everything may no longer hold. Theo, who had popularized that approach, asks for an independent investigation using Claude Code logs stored in ClickHouse, signaling that the reported change still needs verification beyond Melaugh’s analysis and example.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.