hn.today

I got banned from Lobsters for writing like an LLM

en.andros.dev9 points2 comments
Screenshot of I got banned from Lobsters for writing like an LLM

Andros Fenollosa recounts being banned from Lobsters, a technology discussion community where he had participated for years, contributed links and comments, built an Emacs client, and joined the IRC channel. His website domain had been blocked for self-promotion despite his saying he had not previously submitted his own work there; moderators did not respond when he asked why. Nearly a year later, he found a way around the block and shared a post about building a modern bulletin-board system. The submission attracted discussion and reached the front page, but users accused him of using AI to write his replies, citing an AI-detection service, and increasingly flagged the thread as spam. Fenollosa denied using AI and asked moderators for help, but received no response until they removed the post under the self-promotion rule.

When he asked how to distinguish useful knowledge-sharing from promotion, a moderator advised improving his ratio of community contributions to self-promotional material. Two hours later, his account was banned for “Only self-promo, slop.” He appealed, explaining the circumstances and asking to return as a commenter, but again received no answer. Fenollosa questions the use of AI detectors as proof and worries that detailed, polished writing now invites suspicion, pushing people toward terse, casual replies to seem human. He also considers the tension between individual contributors and community moderation, while acknowledging that Lobsters can enforce its own rules. He says he would return only to comment, and plans to share his work elsewhere.

Read on en.andros.dev2 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.