hn.today

How Should Armies Fight?

worksinprogress.co35 points65 comments
Screenshot of How Should Armies Fight?

Jack Watling’s The Arms of the Future argues that modern warfare is being reshaped by the growing reach of sensors, the range of weapons, and the accuracy of munitions. Consumer drones, commercial satellites, radar, acoustic devices, and tools that detect electronic signals can expose troops and vehicles over great distances. Meanwhile, artillery can strike far-off targets with precision: compared with guns of 80 years ago, today’s heavy artillery reaches much farther and misses by far less. Together, these advances make it increasingly difficult for armies to assemble forces secretly and launch the concentrated, surprise attacks that once defined successful offensives. Near the front, even vehicle groups can be detected and destroyed, while the dangerous zone extends ever farther into what used to be the rear.

Watling’s proposed response is to attack the enemy’s ability to see. Dispersing and digging in can protect troops but makes offensives slow and costly; cities offer shelter and preserve mobility, but surrendering the countryside risks encirclement. Instead, he envisions small, mobile units that hunt sensors and deploy their own, backed by long-range artillery and specialized troops for assaults on cities and strongpoints. The aim is to create brief openings for forces to gather and seize a limited objective, not to restore sweeping armored offensives. Ukraine’s battlefield reflects the book’s predictions: soldiers spend long periods underground, urban positions are valuable, and Russian attacks suffer heavy losses. Some Ukrainian units have begun targeting sensors before advancing, but this approach will work only while they can keep the enemy blind.

Read on worksinprogress.co65 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Other

Microsoft – more details on the root cause

Microsoft – more details on the root cause

A latent lock-contention bug in Microsoft 365 networking gateways combined with increased traffic and 14% of capacity being offline, triggering a global outage during peak U.S. usage. Microsoft said routine load tests missed the defect because they used different traffic patterns and lower-core hardware, and the fix was limited to Microsoft 365 gateway servers. (twitter.com)

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.