A late-night attempt to rank the Byrds’ albums leads the writer to question a vivid memory: that, around 1967 or 1968, he ordered the band’s first four albums together through the Columbia Record Club. He recalls receiving 12 albums in his first shipment and worrying that he was using too many choices on one group, but contemporary advertisements he finds do not confirm the exact selection. Other details partly fit: some ads offered 12 records, and he remembers using order numbers across multiple ads. He is more certain that he acquired the Byrds’ first seven albums through the club, played them repeatedly, and later received several subsequent albums in separate shipments.
The uncertainty matters because he is trying to understand a remembered claim that he liked the Byrds more than the Beatles. If he listened intensively to the Byrds before getting Beatles albums through another record club, that preference may have been genuine for a time, even though he now considers the Beatles more talented. The episode becomes a reflection on memory as an imperfect, malleable record that can produce false details, unlike the more deliberate storage of computer systems. As he turns 75, preserving memory feels bound up with preserving his identity; he wishes he had kept contemporaneous records that could verify his recollections.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.