hn.today

Grim Fandango Puzzle Document (1996) [pdf]

gameshelf.jmac.org264 points59 comments
Screenshot of Grim Fandango Puzzle Document (1996) [pdf]

Commenters discussed a Tim Schafer-era Grim Fandango puzzle design document, mixing nostalgia for the game's art, music and writing with practical notes about its puzzles and remaster. Several praised Schafer's voice and the document's personality: leokennis called small jokes "delightful," PetitPrince and polytely praised Schafer and Double Fine's storytelling and documentary work (polytely recommended a Psychonauts 2 doc series). Players like fredrikholm and jug shared fond memories of the game's atmosphere and ending music, while sersi and others recommended the remastered release for improved controls. Some noted technical issues: dariosalvi78 mentioned crashes, and jimbob45 warned of anti-logic puzzles that frustrate some players.

Opinion split over whether the PDF is a lightweight, charming design artifact or a flimsy foundation: vbernat, wodenokoto and TZubiri labeled it a puzzle or game-design document (PDD/GDD) and enjoyed the behind-the-scenes peek, while snickerer and others questioned its depth versus being a walkthrough. Critics focused on specific puzzle design - several called parts maddening or requiring a guide - whereas many still regarded the overall experience as brilliant and unique, and gyomu and others recommended related talks and videos for further context.

Read on gameshelf.jmac.org59 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Other

Effective Altruism Is Evil

Effective Altruism Is Evil

Trey Goff argues that effective altruism is an evil ideology that promotes a utilitarian and consequentialist approach to maximizing the reduction of suffering, often through mathematical calculations. He claims it leads to systemic problems by prioritizing the greatest good for the greatest number, including non-human beings, over individual moral considerations. (twitter.com)

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.