GrapheneOS accuses Google of deliberately restricting access to Android 17 QPR1 features and security fixes, saying the September Pixel Drop introduced developer APIs and changes that were not made available via AOSP. That marks, according to GrapheneOS, the first time since Honeycomb that new APIs landed without being upstreamed for everyone. Although Google published developer documentation and provided QPR1 GSI builds for developers, GrapheneOS reports it ported its code to QPR1 before release but lacks permission to distribute those changes, forcing the project to backport Pixel firmware, kernel drivers, userspace drivers, and HALs into Android 17 instead.
GrapheneOS also calls out Google for including additional security patches in the Pixel Update Bulletin that are absent from the standard Android Security Bulletin and OEM preview patches, asserting some of those fixes affect platform components used broadly across Android devices. The project warns this practice gives Pixel phones an advantage and makes Pixels harder for third-party projects to support. GrapheneOS says OEMs and AOSP-based projects will likely only receive those platform fixes with Android 17 QPR2 in December, and notes an upcoming Motorola partnership could ease future device support by providing official firmware and driver code.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.