hn.today

GPS and the Lost Art of Getting Lost

newyorker.com100 points100 comments
Screenshot of GPS and the Lost Art of Getting Lost

GPS began as a U.S. Department of Defense project in the 1970s and entered civilian life after 2000; within a decade there were roughly a billion receivers worldwide. Satellite navigation locates a receiver by trilateration, using signals from at least four satellites to compute distance from precise timestamps, and modern positioning now includes European, Russian, and Chinese constellations. Katherine Dunn’s new book Little Blue Dot and interviews with neuroscientists and historians trace how a military technology became an invisible guiding hand, centering digital maps on a user’s blue dot and changing how people conceptualize place and movement.

The change matters because it shifts the neural and practical basis of wayfinding. Cognitive mapping relies on hippocampal place cells and landmark-based spatial representations; GPS-driven, turn-by-turn directions favor stimulus-response routines and habitual learning. Empirical work documents the effect: a 2008 study found that walkers guided by GPS were worse at drawing the routes they had taken and estimating direction, and a 2020 McGill experiment showed heavier GPS users performed worse on cognitive-mapping mazes and noticed fewer landmarks. Regional G.P.S. spoofing in Israel produced a natural experiment: a neuroscientist surveyed nearly six hundred people in affected areas and found about eighty percent still reached destinations despite disruptions while roughly twenty to twenty-five percent struggled significantly; pilots and ship captains in the region have disabled automated safety systems because of spoofing and jamming.

Concrete tradeoffs and limits are visible in everyday stories and tests. Older navigators - truck drivers, pizza deliverers, park rangers - describe relying on atlases, CB tips, and U.S. Geological Survey maps before switching to GPS, and report weaker route memory after adopting digital directions. Mistakes driven by blind trust in GPS have stranded trucks on narrow roads, wedged cars on light-rail tracks, and sent vehicles toward cliffs or into lakes. Experiments without GPS, such as orienteering courses, reveal lost skills in locating starting points and reading topography, underscoring the practical cost of convenience and the technological vulnerability introduced by dependence on external signals.

Read on newyorker.com100 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.