Google’s AI Overviews have expanded from 5.9% of tracked search results in September 2024 to 61.4% in August 2026, while featured snippets have nearly disappeared. A randomized experiment with US desktop users found that searches showing an Overview produced 0.37 clicks to outside sites, compared with 0.62 when Overviews were hidden - a 39.8% drop. Searches with no outbound click rose from 54% to 73%, while ad clicks were unchanged. The experiment estimates an 18.5% loss in organic clicks across all searches; Pew’s browsing data also shows fewer ordinary-result clicks when summaries appear. Desktop click-through rates fell sharply, though the data cannot establish that Overviews caused the full decline.
The practical case for generative engine optimization is limited: it largely resembles conventional SEO, with an emphasis on earning links from sites AI systems draw on and presenting information in a form that is easy to quote. Referring-domain counts correlate moderately with AI citations, but that does not prove links cause citations or explain how to get cited initially. Google and ChatGPT also favor different sources, so visibility on one does not ensure visibility on the other; Reddit and Wikipedia are prominent in both. Despite the growing attention to AI citations, AI assistants sent websites only 0.3% of their traffic in March. The central challenge is therefore lost search visits, with no demonstrated GEO tactic yet shown to replace them. The main experiment is a working paper based on desktop users, and other traffic comparisons have limitations.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.