Commenters disagree over whether personal agents solve a real need. Skeptics say most people do not need help managing calendars or shopping, and warn that automated purchasing could expose users to overpriced offers. Some question whether Gemini can genuinely infer useful insights from bills or other personal data, while others see the feature as another way to feed information to Google or to demonstrate workplace productivity gains. Several also express uncertainty about the product’s place among Google’s many AI offerings, including whether it overlaps with Google Tasks or competes with persistent-agent products such as Muse.
Others describe agents as increasingly useful for shopping, travel planning, recurring reports, health tracking, and coordinating apps or projects, arguing that practical applications are expanding. A commenter in their 60s says agents have changed how they handle many online tasks, directly contrasting with another commenter of the same age who sees no need for them. Even enthusiasts report that Gemini Tasks can be frustrating: it repeatedly asks for approvals, inconsistently finds connected tools, and offers little control over reasoning or automation. Commenters also question whether the feature will last, with some expecting it to be renamed or folded into another product rather than disappear. The divide is between skepticism about demand, reliability, and data costs, and optimism that agents can become useful everyday assistants.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.