GNU Emacs maintainer Eli Zaretskii was asked on a public development list whether the project should knowingly accept technically sound code produced by enslaved people, where local law grants ownership of the work and copyright is assigned to the Free Software Foundation. He answered, “Our answer must be YES,” arguing that another response would divide the community over political and ideological disputes unrelated to software freedom. When challenged about slavery and child slavery, he said he did not tolerate slavery but did not ask contributors about their views, and compared the hypothetical with accepting work from countries whose governments others condemn.
The central argument is that this response confuses legal permission with ethical obligation: valid ownership and working code do not prove a project must accept them. The essay argues that calling ethical scrutiny divisive shields existing practices from examination, invoking Hume’s distinction between facts and moral duties and Mary Wollstonecraft’s rebuttal to Edmund Burke’s claim that judging institutions fractures society. It connects that reasoning to defenses of the slave trade and warns that it could similarly protect coerced labor in software development. GNU already treats provenance as relevant by rejecting disclosed LLM-generated code pending legal advice; the dispute, the essay contends, is that copyright documentation counts as provenance while forced labor is dismissed as irrelevant.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.