hn.today

Everything Made by an AI Is in the Public Domain

pluralistic.net7 points3 comments
Screenshot of Everything Made by an AI Is in the Public Domain

A federal judge upheld the US Copyright Office’s position that works generated by AI without human authorship cannot receive copyright protection. Copyright, as described here, requires creative expression fixed in a tangible form and attributable to a human; an AI-generated image, text, recording, or video therefore belongs to the public domain. The ruling matters to creative workers because it raises the cost to employers of replacing them with software: companies could use AI outputs, but could not prevent others from copying, selling, or adapting those outputs. The author sees this loss of exclusive rights as leverage for writers, performers, and other workers negotiating over AI use.

The argument is that concentrated entertainment businesses have gained from decades of expanded copyright while creative workers’ wages have fallen, so stronger individual rights do not necessarily improve workers’ bargaining position. If companies want protected, exclusive products, they have reason to keep human creators involved and pay them. The piece also separates AI training from infringement: analyzing copyrighted works and building models from that analysis are generally not copyright violations, while a particular generated output may infringe, with responsibility resting on the user. It suggests that lawsuits against AI firms may instead turn on how they collected, sorted, or filtered training data, including potentially unlawful practices.

Read on pluralistic.net3 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

Stripe Press

Stripe Press

Stripe Press publishes books and multimedia about ideas, business, technology, and society. Its catalog includes titles on engineering, startups, science, and AI, alongside films, podcasts, and digital editions. (stripe.press)

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.