hn.today

eMudhra ignored Mozilla Root investigation deadline; blames social media

bugzilla.mozilla.org181 points133 comments
Screenshot of eMudhra ignored Mozilla Root investigation deadline; blames social media

Commenters focus on eMudhra’s failure to meet Mozilla Root Program’s response deadline and the company’s claim that intense social media scrutiny and investor pressure impeded timely technical analysis. IcePenguin highlights Mozilla’s note that eMudhra missed an initial 24-hour response and a requested 24-hour extension. ForHackernews defends eMudhra’s explanation, saying legal review and furious stakeholders can delay a sober RCA, while antonvs and others call that excuse ridiculous and demand accountability. Several ask what leverage root programs have now that eMudhra has ceased issuing TLS certificates, and note Sectigo revoked cross‑signed certificates quickly, which some see as appropriate mitigation.

The discussion shifts to technical blame and systemic issues. Bradfa, tonymet and bob1029 point at poor HSM practices, weak generated private keys and possible imports or workaround use of wrap/unwrap features; nraynaud mocks the improbably tiny keys. Others, including tptacek and cpburns2009, argue the WebPKI model that lets any trusted CA issue for any domain is broken and propose limiting scope (or using DNSSEC), while opponents note DNSSEC deployment problems. Tamimio and several commenters demand stronger accountability for real‑world harms, and many emphasize tooling, process and vendor responsibilities rather than treating this as merely a publicity problem.

Read on bugzilla.mozilla.org133 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Security

1984: The Canadian Edition

1984: The Canadian Edition

Canada’s proposed Bill C-22 would let officials compel digital services to assist surveillance and create law-enforcement access, raising concerns about security and privacy. Signal, NordVPN, Windscribe, and other companies say they could limit services or leave Canada if the bill passes. (btxx.org)

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.