AI agents risk extending the internet’s surveillance-driven business model, which profits from collecting personal data for advertising, personalization, and AI training. Unlike ordinary apps, agents may access intimate information across accounts and conversations, operate autonomously over time, and delegate work to other systems across organizational or legal boundaries. This breadth makes their actions harder to monitor and creates opportunities to manipulate users. Standard consent practices - long notices followed by a few clicks - do not provide meaningful control, and companies’ promises of privacy cannot be trusted while their incentives favor collecting more data.
Governments should require data minimization as a legally enforceable default: agents may collect and use only what is strictly necessary for a task the user has explicitly specified and authorized, with exceptions only for genuinely informed consent. Clear task limits and explicit permissions would help keep agents within their mandate, strengthen accountability, and reduce threats to privacy, autonomy, cognitive security, and democracy. Minimizing stored and shared information also lowers the consequences of breaches by reducing the data available to steal. The authors argue that these protections are feasible and should not be sacrificed in the name of convenience or innovation. Since companies are unlikely to abandon data maximization voluntarily, governments must act while agentic systems are still being developed.
Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.