hn.today

Complex Systems Won't Survive the Competence Crisis (2023)

palladiummag.com4 points2 comments
Screenshot of Complex Systems Won't Survive the Competence Crisis (2023)

The argument is that a series of seemingly unrelated U.S. failures - from naval collisions and wildfires to supply-chain disruptions, railway accidents, and contaminated medicine - reflects a broader decline in the competence needed to run interconnected systems. Because modern infrastructure depends on many organizations working reliably, failures can spread across sectors. The author traces this decline to a shift away from merit-based selection, which expanded in the early twentieth century through aptitude testing and helped staff major scientific and engineering projects. In the author’s account, civil-rights-era rules made measurable group representation an overriding institutional priority, weakening direct evaluation of ability and leaving complex systems more prone to accidents.

The piece describes how employers responded to legal risks around testing by relying on elite educational credentials, then faced pressure to favor diversity in hiring and promotion. It portrays that pressure as coming from multiple sources, including executives, human-resources teams, clients, and employee groups. Diversity policies first encourage broad candidate slates and structured interviews; when these measures do not meet targets, hiring managers face stronger incentives, and job requirements may be relaxed to widen the pool. The author argues that this can mean less evidence of candidates’ readiness and more risk of poor hires, while termination becomes difficult. Diversity-linked performance targets intensify the pressure, especially in hierarchical organizations. The conclusion is stark: unless institutions restore competence as a central selection principle, the country’s ability to operate complex systems - and its global power - will deteriorate.

Read on palladiummag.com2 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Culture

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.