hn.today

A Perfect SimCity

jeffquast.com4 points0 comments
Screenshot of A Perfect SimCity

Using the open-source Micropolis version of 1989 SimCity and automated experiments, Jeff Quast investigates what the game’s city score actually rewards. The highest-scoring cities reach about 937-950 points with only 12,000-18,000 residents: they keep taxes at 1%, use few roads, and rely on pollution-free rail. Police and fire departments are often omitted because their budgets raise costs, while roads create traffic and pollution. A major scoring quirk is that excess jobs produce negative unemployment penalties, adding as much as roughly 128 points. The game also penalizes cities for lacking a stadium, airport, or seaport, though the latter two can hurt scores through pollution.

The experiments expose other counterintuitive rules. Fountains can improve the crime average because their tiles are counted in scoring even though they have no residents; parks and trees do not directly remove pollution, and too much greenery can overflow a limited land-value calculation and lower value. Industrial zones can be useful at map edges, where land is less suitable for other development. By contrast, population-focused designs reach roughly 670,000-709,000 residents but score only about 458-525, with more crime, pollution, and higher taxes. Quast argues that the game’s scoring system rewards carefully engineered scarcity - especially excess jobs and limited housing - rather than a prosperous, densely populated city, echoing similar counterintuitive incentives in earlier urban simulations.

Read on jeffquast.com0 comments on Hacker News

Summary generated by AI from the linked article. hn.today is not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator.

More in Other

The daily digest

Today's best Hacker News stories, summarized and screenshotted, one email a day.